ALBUM REVIEW
EYES OF AGONY – When They Return
Old-school death metal with melodic depth.

Bringing together several seasoned names from the Italian death metal scene, EYES OF AGONY make their debut with "When They Return", presenting a lineup well versed in the traditions of old-school death metal. At the heart of the project is guitarist Danny Cinicolo, known for his work with established fixtures of the Italian underground such as EXCIDIUM and MALEFICARUM. Initially conceived as a personal musical endeavour, EYES OF AGONY eventually evolved into a five-piece featuring Andrea Zanetti on vocals, Davide Billia on drums, Massimo Boffa on guitar and Fabrizio Biondi on bass. Given the members' backgrounds, it comes as little surprise that "When They Return" stays firmly rooted in traditional death metal. The real question is how effectively that collective experience translates into the songwriting.
Spanning nine tracks and clocking in at 36 minutes, the album gets off to a hard-hitting start with 'Infected Lands', following the brief acoustic introduction of 'The Blackening Of The Skies'. The track's old-school death metal character emerges through groove-driven guitar riffs woven between rapid-fire drum patterns. This approach continues on 'Altars Of Hate', where frequent blast beats never reduce the music to a one-dimensional exercise in speed. In particular, the sharp interplay between guitar and bass, reinforced by the relentless drumming, prevents the compositions from relying solely on velocity. Davide Billia's performance plays a significant role here. His tight double-bass work and relentless blast-beat passages give the music considerable physical weight, while his rhythmic shifts preserve a sense of movement within the compositions.

Defining EYES OF AGONY solely through aggression, however, would mean overlooking the album's melodic side. With its more measured progression and sinister melodic undercurrent, 'As Angels Fall' breaks away from the high-velocity atmosphere established by the opening tracks. 'And Life Slips Away' and 'Resuscitation Failed' also balance technical intensity with melodic ideas. Rather than simply delivering riffs, the guitars establish melodic connections that help shape the atmosphere of each song, allowing the album to explore a broader expressive range within the boundaries of traditional death metal. In this respect, the music moves between passages reminiscent of AT THE GATES' melodic death metal approach and the harsher, darker traditions of American death metal. However, the combination of these two approaches does not produce equally compelling results throughout the album.
With its deliberate pace and imposing atmosphere, 'Underworlds Of Atrocity' recalls the earlier work of NILE. The reduction in speed brings the weight of the riffs and the track's melodic tension further into focus. Another defining aspect of Danny Cinicolo's guitar writing becomes apparent in passages like these. The solos feel less like flashy interruptions detached from the songs' overall character and more like natural extensions of the compositions. Appearing at various points throughout the album, these guitar leads expand its melodic content while keeping the technical side of old-school death metal alive. Cinicolo's choices in this regard demonstrate a successful ability to incorporate modern songwriting elements into a traditional genre framework.
On the vocal front, Andrea Zanetti delivers a predominantly intense and forceful performance. His vocal approach fits the music's aggressive character, but its relatively narrow expressive range becomes noticeable in sections that could benefit from greater variation. The occasional deeper, harsher screams break up this uniformity and bring a different dimension to his performance. A similar assessment applies to the production. The mixing and mastering, handled by Luca Nicolucci at Comet Broadcasting Studio, bring out the dynamic character of the guitars and the sheer intensity of the drums. However, the somewhat artificial quality of the drums in certain passages slightly diminishes the impact of the organic instrumental performances. Considering the album's old-school identity in particular, a more natural drum tone could have contributed more effectively to its overall aesthetic.
As the album approaches its closing stretch, 'Eyes Of Agony' and 'When They Return' revisit songwriting approaches already explored in the preceding tracks. Although both songs fit the album's overall direction, their riffs and rhythmic dynamics begin to lean more heavily on familiar formulas, resulting in a slight decline in creativity towards the end. The melodic and rhythmic variety EYES OF AGONY demonstrate particularly well in the album's middle section is not sustained to the same degree in its final stages. Greater contrasts in tempo, more varied riff transitions and clearer distinctions in character between the compositions could have strengthened the album as a whole.
"When They Return" is a respectful debut from a group of experienced musicians who clearly understand the foundations of old-school death metal. Drawing on different strands of the genre represented by INCANTATION, NILE, CANNIBAL CORPSE and DEATH, the band attempts to bring these influences together through its own songwriting rather than simply imitating them. While not all nine tracks display the same level of creativity, strong riff writing, well-placed solos and the interplay between melody and aggression are central to the album's appeal. The biggest challenge ahead for EYES OF AGONY will be to combine their technical capabilities with bolder songwriting decisions. "When They Return" serves as a reminder that old-school death metal remains a compelling form of expression, while also demonstrating that establishing a lasting identity within the tradition requires more than simply bringing the right ingredients together.

facebook.com/eyesofagony
awakeningrecordscn.bandcamp.com
facebook.com/AwakeningRecordsCN
awakeningrecordscn.bigcartel.com
instagram.com/awakeningrecordscn
youtube.com/@AwakeningRecordsCN

