ALBUM REVIEW
MYSTIC PROPHECY – In Metal
Traditional Heavy Metal with uneven songwriting.

MYSTIC PROPHECY’s “In Metal”, arriving three and a half years after its predecessor, remains firmly rooted in the Heavy and Power Metal sound the band has pursued for years, despite significant changes to the lineup. Dan Baune, Tommy Gun and Christophe de Combe join R.D. Liapakis and Markus Pohl to form a new lineup for the band’s thirteenth studio album. How this change would affect the music is a question that arises from the very beginning. After all, the hallmarks of MYSTIC PROPHECY—sharp guitar riffs, big sing-along choruses and tempos that edge towards Speed Metal—remain central to the album.
Opening track ‘Robots’ uses its mechanical, stop-start rhythmic structure to reinforce its lyrical exploration of the increasingly blurred boundary between humans and technology. However, the song’s short, straightforward arrangement struggles to deliver the expected impact, particularly in the chorus. ‘In Metal’, which follows, turns the band’s devotion to Heavy Metal into an anthem. Built around big choruses, accessible guitar parts and gang vocals, the track makes MYSTIC PROPHECY’s live-oriented approach to songwriting abundantly clear. Yet the familiarity of this approach also prevents the song from developing a character of its own.

The rhythmic drive becomes more pronounced on ‘March Or Die’. The drums move across a hard-edged guitar foundation, giving the track a steady, determined momentum, while the marching feel of the chorus maintains the band’s familiar aesthetic. The idea that, beneath the imagery of war, the lyrics are really about pressing on in the face of adversity gives them an additional dimension. Even so, the predictability of the musical structure remains. The same applies to ‘When The Hammer Will Fall’ later on. Evoking Manowar’s warrior-minded take on Heavy Metal, Amon Amarth’s Viking-themed aesthetic and HammerFall’s melodic Power Metal approach, the track treads decidedly familiar ground, particularly in its melodic chorus and the guitar work in the bridge. Despite being well executed, it fails to turn these influences into a songwriting identity of its own.
The album’s more compelling moments emerge when the band moves beyond its customary tales of warriors and battle. ‘Don't Run Away’ takes a more personal approach, addressing fear, depression and the struggle against the darkness within. Its fast pace and distinctive melodic hook make it one of the album’s highlights, not only lyrically but also in terms of its overall musical construction. Unlike the formulaic repetition found on some of the other tracks, the memorable chorus here gives the songwriting genuine momentum.
‘Warhead’ boasts one of the most distinctive arrangements on “In Metal”. The Middle Eastern-inspired rhythmic and melodic touches heard at the beginning and end of the track bring a different colour to the familiar Heavy Metal framework. The arrangement grows heavier as the guitars kick in, ensuring that these brief passages amount to more than mere decoration. The interplay between the aggressive riffs and these culturally evocative sections gives the song an identity rarely found elsewhere on the album. This particular approach demonstrates that MYSTIC PROPHECY can achieve more interesting results without abandoning the musical formula it has relied on for years. ‘Angels Are Falling’, meanwhile, stands out for its fast, hard-hitting verses, while the chorus pulls back the pace to make room for its melodic side. Markus Pohl’s solo is another detail that reinforces the track’s guitar-driven character.
On the album’s quieter side, ‘My Inner Innocence’ takes the band’s melodic approach into a different emotional territory. Its mid-tempo pace, melancholic melodies and half-ballad structure create an atmosphere suited to its exploration of lost innocence, loneliness and the struggle to hold on to a part of oneself. Dan Baune’s playing is particularly noteworthy, with solo and lead passages that enrich the song’s melodic character. A reminder that MYSTIC PROPHECY are not defined solely by high-octane anthems, the composition shows that the band can also deliver when it turns to more introspective themes. ‘Devil's Son’, by contrast, has a darker character, built around dense riffs despite its slower pace. Closing track ‘Warrior Of Asgard’ picks up the speed again, returning to the warrior imagery of Norse mythology. Its guitar work recalls Primal Fear, and its grand-scale chorus makes for an effective finale. However, the Heavy Metal scene has revisited Asgard and warrior themes so often that the song’s scope for originality is limited.
In terms of production, the prominence given to the guitars and drums fits the band’s traditional Heavy Metal approach. The clarity of the riffs and the direct impact of the rhythm section reinforce the album’s potential to translate well to the live stage. Keyboard strings and orchestral touches appear here and there, particularly on ‘Warhead’, but never become prominent enough to alter the overall sound. R.D. Liapakis’s distinctive, slightly raspy yet powerful voice also remains at the heart of the compositions. The new lineup clearly has no trouble gelling on an instrumental level. Dan Baune’s guitar contributions and solos further strengthen that cohesion. The shortcomings of “In Metal”, then, cannot be attributed to the musicians’ performances or the production.
The real issue lies in the selectiveness of the songwriting and the staying power of its melodies. Across its ten tracks, the album offers successful choruses and effective guitar passages, but many of them are not developed enough to leave a lasting impression. The lyrical world built around metal, demons, warriors, Vikings and mythological imagery is consistent with the aesthetic the band has cultivated for years, but repeatedly revisiting these themes in much the same way gradually diminishes their impact. The music faces a similar problem. MYSTIC PROPHECY have a sound of their own, and there is nothing inherently wrong with preserving that identity. However, following releases such as “Hellriot” and “Metal Division”, “In Metal” falls short of the expected standard when it comes to breathing new life into the same formula with fresh, compelling songs.
Ultimately, “In Metal” demonstrates that MYSTIC PROPHECY have retained their experience and musical identity, while also reminding us that these two qualities alone are not enough. Tracks such as ‘Don't Run Away’, ‘Warhead’ and ‘My Inner Innocence’ show that the band can still deliver effective melodies and introduce different musical touches. Yet these moments do not translate into a consistently strong level of songwriting across the album. Despite the new lineup’s successful chemistry, what MYSTIC PROPHECY need on their thirteenth album is not a radical change of style, but a way to make their traditional sound feel meaningful again through stronger songs. “In Metal” meets that expectation in places, but ultimately fails to reach the level set by the band’s previous two releases.


